Don’t Create a Community – Invest in Building a Tribe



Participating in online communities and social media peer groups has become the norm for professionals as part of their daily activities.

Two studies that were tracking how companies leverage communities and social media as part of their business were unveiled at the SCNR Symposium last week.

The 2nd Annual New Symbiosis of Professional Networks Study by Vanessa DiMauro finds that over 80% of respondents access social networks one or more times during the day and consider them reliable sources for their decision making process. They are increasingly turning to social networks, which have evolved from ‘social’ to knowledge & communications networks.

Why is this the case?

An emerging trend in the study says DiMauro, is that “Professionals share and consume quality content with their professional networks as a way of exerting influence.” According to Francois Gossieaux co-author of  The Hyper-Social Organization: Findings from the 4th Annual Tribalization of Business Study, “Humans love status and power. It is used to get them better food and better mates.  Humans also like to horde information; knowledge is power, knowledge is status.”

His research identifies that knowledge sharing is key to effective online communities, but leveraging social networks is disconnected from the development process in most organizations. Gossieaux posits that organizations that have online communities with a tribe mentality; a group of individual with shared interests, passion and pain, are best positioned to leverage the collective knowledge and output of these groups. (IBM is sited as an example of a company who embraces this concept.)

Further, professionals and organizations are now being defined by the quality of content they create and curate.  As DiMaura describes, over 60% of study respondents identified the desire to “establish and increase my professional network” as their top reason for engaging in online communities. The value of an “endorsement” (re: read, share, like, RT) is increasing in importance as a quantifiable metric that can influence decision-making.

Social business is also occurring within these professional communities with 80% reporting that they are able to “accelerate decision process and strategy development” by participating in them.

This study shed light on the types and numbers of communities that professional typically engage in, 1 to 2 large networks and 1 to 2 niche communities.  The more gated the community the more open the communications, the bigger the networks the more cautious the community. Intimate communities are characterized as open & sharing and can include anywhere from 1000 to 3000 participants.

Business professionals are utilizing social networks for sharing and collaboration, but allocation of future budgets are not directed to enhancing the participatory nature of these networks. The top area sited for investment is “more marketing programs and campaigns.”

Similar disconnects between the users of online communities and the sponsors of these social networks are consistent with the results from the Tribalization of Business Study.

Respondents were asked to identify the top 5 business process reasons that companies use to establish online communities:

  • Marketing Thought Leadership
  • Marketing and Promotion
  • Marketing Insight/Research
  • Branding
  • Customer Support

The budgets allocated to these communities seem insufficient to support the objectives – approximately 50% of those surveyed will be spending less then $50,000 a year on their social networks.  The majority of respondents internally staff the management of these communities with 38% of them doing so only on a part time basis.

Still, the business objectives that these organizations have been successful in achieving are in lockstep with the goals of online communities.  Win!

  • Education/Knowledge Sharing
  • Connecting with Peers
  • Collaboration
  • General WOM

Interestingly, the metrics used by companies to track the progress and success of their communities do not reflect the reasons that individuals choose to participate in social networks, which is sharing and collaboration.

What are the top business objectives your company has been successful in achieving via online communities?

  • Increased sales
  • Increased market and competitive intelligence
  • Greater awareness
  • Improved customer satisfaction
  • More referrals

The disconnect between the value of the communities to the participants, and the stated objectives of the sponsoring company will ultimately result in declining memberships.

This is why companies should nurture their communities and let them develop into tribes. By definition tribes are a social division in a traditional society consisting of families or communities linked by social, economic, religious, or blood ties, with a common culture and dialect, typically having a recognized leader.

Great examples of online communities as tribes are Walmart, SAP Developer Network, and Best Buy.

Another excellent example of a tribe is the Occupy movement.

So let your tribes develop and they’ll want to occupy your community!

image: rajkumar1220


Enjoy this post? Make sure you get the latest article delivered to you as soon as it's published by subscribing via RSS or Email (emails are usually sent out the morning after the post goes live). We respect your privacy and will never spam you.
About the author: Anne Weiskopf  (3 Posts)

Anne Weiskopf spent the bulk of her career as a publishing and media executive in the high tech arena. An experienced sales warrior, Anne was instrumental in launching and leading the move to integrated sales across off and online channels at UBM TechWeb. A social creature to begin with, she became enamored with social media and was on the launch team of TWTRCON (now The Realtime Report & Conference.) You can find Anne blogging here, and, at RipOffTheRoof.com.


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
SocializeBrands 5 pts

Interesting Anne, how you see tribes and communities empirically not synonymously. Finally! Indeed, tribes are smaller, more homogeneous, powerful...Communities may indeed be semantics for a bigger bucket of lesser common bonds. This needs to be explored and defined...without any rhetoric. All brands will be faced with 1,000 small tribes (1,000 to 3,000 for example) to be relevant to. They are armed with demographics and superficial "psychographics" i.e. segmentation. Tribes elude them. Not sure the examples above are the best though. Think Zappos, NakedPizza, Etsy (creative crafts community with a thousand tribes), Squidoo (community with a thousand tribes), Occupy (community with a thousand tribes), HOGs (huge Harley Davidson tribe), Vintage car collectors uniting at A&W annually (huge tribe)....so many. My followers are essentially my tribe with more or less gravitas; my tribe forms, synthesizes, purifies, solidifies... I will eventually join many tribes as i have yours today " The Tribe of Anne Weiskopf". #buildtribes @socializebrands

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

SocializeBrands Hi Marie! Sorry for the delay in my response. I was writing a new post for PVSM that is running today (different topic - but funny!) Really appreciate your feedback on tribes, I struggled with how to best define them and how they are different then communities. One of the challenges is that tribes tend to have a leader (of the charismatic variety) and that is the antithesis of the #OccupyMovement though they are tribal in nature. With that - I'm digging your definition of tribes WITHIN communities. That makes sense to me. A lot. The example of Harley Davidson is a great one - did you see this recent story? Harley-Davidson Facebook App Turns Fans Into Marketers http://bit.ly/rsJ6Fx AND - I'm loving the Tribe of Anne Weiskopf" - I think I need tee shirts! :) #buildtribes

SocializeBrands 5 pts

Thank you Anne! Have Tweeted about Francois already and it is in #BuildTribes. Seminal indeed. About to sign-up on your blog too. :-)

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

SocializeBrands Cool. Btw - my main blog is http://www.ripofftheroof.com/. Thanks again!

SocializeBrands 5 pts

Excellent Anne! Saved in my favorites. Have shared widely. You might enjoy http://YouTube.com/TRIBEradio and http://Branding20.wordpress.com. Please post at the new Twitter conversation #buildtribes

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

SocializeBrands Marie, thank you so much for your kind works and for your links. I've signed up for your blog and look forward to reading it. Happy to post at #buildtribes. Definitely find and follow Francois on Twitter!

juliepippert 37 pts

Intriguing on many levels. I find this to be very true, "The more gated the community the more open the communications, the bigger the networks the more cautious the community. Intimate communities are characterized as open & sharing and can include anywhere from 1000 to 3000 participants." Loved your insight into this topic and the rundown. I think this post, the blog and comments are a sort of interesting case study of tribe. KWIM?

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

juliepippert Thanks so much Julie. Starting with @maddiegrant's book Humanise and listening to @fgossieaux speak - really got me thinking about the different levels of authenticity and value that can be created given an environment that isn't artificial and allows room for a community to flourish. While working in the B2B high tech media arena, we often created microsites that were sponsored by customers. While the content clearly added value, the hard ROI metrics placed on performance took away the organic nature that the community could have provided which may have led to it developing into a tribe. The SAP Developer Network is really the best example I've seen where "the inmates run the prison" and boy has it been fantastic for the warden!

HowieSPM 2326 pts

This is really true. But the 'thought exchanges' for me don't happen publicly on the networks themselves. I almost 100% have leveraged the knowledge base of my network off them. Meaning I contact people directly via email, phone or initiate this via direct private messaging.

Blogs are a different monster all together. I know most professionals now go to blogs where great conversations on relative topics take place and while these are semi-public they aren't taking place on the major networks.

When I have tried 'Crowd Sourcing' information from my network. I get crickets 90% of the time. And the 10% I get responses Google is always a better source for content for my problem.

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

HowieSPM Thanks so much for commenting Howie. For me personally I have found that Twitter Chats are the best way to crowdsource knowledge, and the cool part is that you get to meet new folks that may not already be in your network - but - clearly have value to add to your industry, passion, work, etc. What I also love is how meeting someone on Twitter (or other social networks) leads to DMing, emailing, talking, etc - the convergence of social and non-social networks. On the subject of crickets, I have a Bearded Dragon named Mercury. He eats crickets. And they are LOUD! :)

ShellyKramer 119 pts

An awesome post, Anne. And had to first share it with a client or two before responding. I'm a big believer in the value of small, closed, engaged communities and the value they provide. Thanks for providing such a great overview of the conference - it sounds fantastic!

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

ShellyKramer thank you so much Shelly! I'm honored that you shared my post with your clients. The conference was truly amazing. There are several more presentations that I'd like to share more broadly. I'm still amazed by the initiative being taken by kdpaine on standardizing social media measurement across advertising and PR. 2012 should be an interesting year!

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

Good morning Tonia. Thanks so much for commenting. You are absolutely right, knowledge has always been power - which is why 'knowledge hoarding' has for centuries been the norm. My take on what has shifted is that in the social web knowledge is currency and the more people that are sharing your 'money' the richer you get. And, if we can use our social currency for Prada shoes - I'm all for it!!!

tim_harrap 5 pts

If you convert "money" to love then you truly have the equation for the new connectedness - to give is better than to receive.

AnneWeiskopf 41 pts

tim_harrap thank you for a beautiful thought to start off this week!

tonia_ries 117 pts

"Occupy your communities" - I love it. It's interesting to look at it this way -- knowledge has always been a social currency. It used to be that knowing where the juicy berry patch was would give you a better chance of finding a mate. Now I can use my social currency to get free Axe hair gel. Wait -- are we going the wrong direction? ;-)

My latest conversation: Social Network Stats of the Week: Google+ Launches Brand Pages, #RLTM Scoreboard

ShellyKramer 119 pts

tonia_ries Does Axe make hair gel, too? Dude, I'm all over that!

dc2fla 12 pts

ShellyKramertonia_ries

Does it work? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4N5j9LMF73k&feature=player_embedded

tonia_ries 117 pts

dc2flaShellyKramer OMG that is too funny. Ken, I'd say it definitely works for you! :-)

My latest conversation: Social Network Stats of the Week: Google+ Launches Brand Pages, #RLTM Scoreboard

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Don’t Create a Community – Invest in Building a Tribe How are you looking to succeed in social media? Everyone speaks about community – but do you need a tribe instead? Source: http://www.punkviewsonsocialmedia.com [...]